Top 10 Halloween Treat Alternatives for Teachers and Parents - No Candy Required

Top 10 Halloween Treat Alternatives for Teachers and Parents - No Candy Required

Whether you’re a teacher who wants a no-candy classroom this October, a parent who plans to offer both candy and non-candy options to trick-or-treaters, or you’ve got kids at home or at school with dietary needs that make candy a hard pass, you are not alone. More and more adults are choosing to swap at least some of the sugar for fun, non-food treats that still feel like a win to kids.

Whatever your reason, the good news is there are plenty of great Halloween alternatives that don’t involve food and still get the thumbs up from kids. Look no further for fun, funny, and festive Halloween treat ideas, including our own stinky sticker twist.

---

Spooky AND sweet! Check out our Halloween Shop for scratch-and-sniff sticker bundles, candy scents, and seasonal stickers.

---

Why Skip Candy This Year?

Candy is a classic sweet treat, but it’s not always the right fit.

Schools have rules about what can and can’t be shared. Some kids can’t have or don’t like certain foods. And sugar + classrooms is not every adult’s idea of a good time. Even for households that do still give out candy, it’s become increasingly common to also offer a non-food option that every kid can enjoy.

That’s why non-candy Halloween treats have gone from “alternative” to expected — and yes, they can still make kids squeal with joy and enjoy the holiday.

Here are our top 10 ideas to stock for your class, home, or trunk-or-treat.

---

Top 10 Halloween Treat Alternatives

1) Scratch-and-Sniff Stickers (Dr. Stinky–approved)

Kids get the thrill (and smell) without the mess. We’ve got 15 different candy scents from Tootsie Roll to Blow Pop.

👉Shop Candy Stickers

2) Mini Pop-It Fidgets

Endlessly entertaining, and great for kids with sensory needs. Perfect for classrooms or party bags.

3) Halloween-Themed Pencils & Erasers

Something kids can use to remember the fun of Halloween is sure to be a hit. Think skull-shaped erasers, bat pencils, and pumpkin grips.

4) Glow Sticks & Finger Lights

Instant excitement, especially during evening events or trunk-or-treat nights. Most glow sticks are non-toxic and glow for up to 6 hours or more.

5) Temporary Tattoos

They’re fast, cheap, and classroom-friendly. Bonus points for spooky designs or themes that can work with popular Halloween costumes. 

6) Bubbles

Everyone loves bubbles! While they might be too much of a temptation in classrooms, sealed packs of bubbles make a great option for trick-or-treat.

7) “Spooky Coupons"

Kids love “pick your prize" coupons and if you’ve got a little extra time, they’re practically free to make. Think about what motivates kids, like getting to choose the story for storytime or have first pick of activities.

8) Mini Costume Props

Simple rings or bracelets, paper masks, or stick on mustaches all create an instant Halloween moment. Be sure to pick items that are age appropriate.

9) Halloween Mini Toys

Plastic spiders, stretchy skeletons, witch fingers, and more bring a smile to trick-or-treaters' faces. Tiny things can add up to big reactions.

10) Slime

Not for the faint of heart, but extremely on-brand for “gross Halloween fun."

---

What can teachers hand out instead of candy on Halloween?

Here are ideas teachers consistently use in classrooms without food:

✅Reward stickers
✅Glow sticks
✅Themed pencils or erasers
✅Mini fidget toys
✅Printable reward coupons

No sugar highs, no sticky hands — just fun.

---

Sneak This Into Goodie Bags Without Getting Boo’d

Kids don’t actually care that it’s not candy. They care that it feels like a treat. And scratch-and-sniff stickers check every Halloween box:

👻Portable
👻Funny and collectible
👻Instant reaction when they’re scratched
👻School-friendly
👻No mess
.
👉 Shop Halloween Stickers & Bundles now

Halloween treats don’t have to mean candy. Whether you’re filling a classroom reward bin or party favor bags, these treats deliver excitement without the sugar crash.

Stay stinky, stay spooky, and hand out something worth screaming about.